What Error Checking Will S+ Engineering 2.1 Perform on ADAPT Blocks?

Right now, Composer (up to S+ Engineering 1.5) is the gold standard of configuration support in the INFI 90 family. This noteworthy tool made people forget about DOS CADEWS and WinCAD because it was so much more capable and robust.

.

One of its deficiencies, however, is that it fails to find many errors that can be a problem. Will S+ Engineering 2.1 (the POSTGRES SQL form) protect users from potentially significant vulnerabilities with useful messages pertaining to ADAPT blocks?

.

DBDOC detects the following FC24 Adapt block errors and warnings in Composer projects. Will S+ Engineering?

.

Block adapts a block that is already adapted

- invisible but bad

- nearly always the result of incomplete cloning of valid logic

- always an error in that the intended target block is NOT adapted

- block order can also make the prototype target block get the WRONG value

https://gmcl.com/Help/build_error_117.html

.

Spec is illegally adapted

- cold reload can fail to execute

- often indicates AO/L block or other alarm limits that are tunable but not adaptable

https://gmcl.com/Help/build_error_83.html

.

Adapt block: Adapted block does not exist

- module can fail to execute

- target block often has been renumbered but the adapt block missed

https://gmcl.com/Help/build_error_21.html

.

Adapt block: Spec out of range

- S3 indicates a specification that block S2 does not have

- we do not know what happens when this is loaded and execution attempted

https://gmcl.com/Help/build_error_20.html

.

Adapt type mismatch

- can indicate a logic problem

- is often enough legal

https://gmcl.com/Help/build_error_169.html

.

Which of these errors does S+ Engineering 2.1 detect? They all can bite.


By Geoff Michaels on 8/18/2017 | Like (0) | Report

Here are good counts for these errors in my samples:

Already adapted (missed adapt) - 446 instances in 74 of 257 projects

Illegally adapte (will not execute on cold reload) - 25 instances in 11 of 257 projects

Adapt block does not exist (will not execute on cold reload) - 53 instances in 20 of 257 projects

Adapted spec out of range (will not execute on cold reload) - 1 instance in 1 of 257 projects

Adapt type mismatch - often used deliberately
- used 192 times in one project
- used 138 times in another project
- 60 instances in 15 other projects


Add New Comment


Geoff Michaels   

asked 3 months ago
Closed



Answers

0

Hi Geoff,
Whilst not talking specifically about S+ Engineering 2.1 or future versions, the current Composer / S+ Engineering Block Manager and Tuning Line function help to address some of the long standing issues with the configuration of ADAPT, MUX, DEMUX, RECIPE and TSTALM blocks right now, particularly when cloning logic or dropping macros. The Primary Interface Manual for Composer / S+ Engineering has more information.

Cheers,

Alan

Alan   

answered 3 months ago


 


By Geoff Michaels on 8/20/2017 | Like (0) | Report

Thanks, Alan. I am aware that complex techniques in the initial engineering of logic using these blocks can allow renumbering, perhaps cloning, correctly. I do not know of any clients who know about them, nor have I ever seen an instance of the text based technique described to me being used in a system.

When a third of the INFI 90 systems I checked have existing ADAPT block issues, it is evidence that the error checking I am asking about is not done in Composer compiles at present. S+ Engineering 2.1 will import existing Composer projects. The question remain about flagging existing errors.

What NEW error checking will S+ Engineering 2.1 introduce along with a new and better database engine? I have laid out five common enough errors - will any of them be detected?


Add New Comment


0

SPE 2.1 is not yet officially released, so can not be answered

This is not the right forum to discuss the issues on product under Development

Deshabhushan   

answered 3 months ago


 


By Geoff Michaels on 8/21/2017 | Like (0) | Report

Thanks.

This is a forum for experts. Who else ought to have knowledge about this area? The product is scheduled for release Q2 of 2018, so it better have important things developed by now. It will be used for systems controlling plants worth many billions.

If people are not already testing this type of error detection, one must conclude it is not included. In two decades, Composer never implemented this. Obviously, if SPE 2.1 will do this, the feature must already be in place and under test by the alpha / beta sites. So far, information I was given privately was that there is not yet any significant new error checking implemented.

There are risks and vulnerabilities involved that I am sure you and other experts understand. Do you think these should be addressed by SPE 2.1?


Add New Comment



Get weekly AKS updates


Partner Exclusive Webinars

 

> – Login to the partner portal to register



Points Redemption Program - Redeem your points for ABB training, Bluetooth speakers and mugs. Terms and conditions >


Earn points when you refer a friend
AKS Referral Program is "Live" - Learn more



AKS Experts


avatar
Ask Stefan Stromqvist   

Rank: 1

I joined ABB in the year of 1994 and has since 1999 been working as a Service & Support Engineer at BU Control Technologies in Västerås, Sweden. My areas of expertise are: 800xA Base, 800xA for Advant Master, Information Management, operating systems, RNRP and Ethernet comms/networking in general.


avatar
Ask Dieter Henkel   

Rank: 23


avatar
Ask Harsha.D   

Rank: 6

Tech.Support,software and commisioning engineer with Proficient knowledge in 800xA and its products, RNRP,Networking in general.


avatar
Ask Sumit Gargav   

Rank: 2

I have worked with Freelance in majority, with 800xA FD and Melody system partly. Also had opportunity to work with Protocols - HART,Profibus,FF & Modbus.


avatar
Ask MMM   

Rank: 5

ABB PA CT Technical Support


avatar
Ask Flavio Mussolin   

Rank: 4

ABB AVP, Senior Electronic and Automation Engineer with over 30 years of experience in the field of process automation automotive, pharmaceutical, hollow glass, steel and rolling.


avatar
Ask Govindaraj   

Rank: 10

Working in ABB India Operation Center. Have Project engineering and commissioning experience in ABB 800xA, Freelance, AC500.


avatar
Ask nikismith   

Rank: 266

I have been a part of the Recording & Control Factory team for 17 years in total, having spent a number of years as a repairs technician withi the manufacturing department, but being in my current role for 9 years now.


avatar
Ask Rob Lyon   

Rank: 3

info@lymac.co.nz I'm an independent DCS software and commissioning engineer with extensive experience in 800xA and other ABB products. I've worked in almost every corner of the world and still haven't seen it all.


avatar
Ask kstoilov   

Rank: 15

Control System Engineer: 800xA, Compact 800, AC500, AC31-50, Advant Master, Simatic, AC&DC Drives 11 years worked for ABB - Control Systems